David Babakaiff
Written by David Babakaiff · Co-Founder, VanPlex | 25+ Years BC Construction Last reviewed: October 2026

San Francisco | Demolition and Historic Buildings

San Francisco Demolition, Tenant Protections and Historic Buildings

Most San Francisco lots already hold a building, and many hold tenants. Two sets of rules decide whether that building can come down or be changed: Planning Code Section 317 and the 2026 Tenant Protection Ordinance, which govern the loss of homes, and Articles 10 and 11, which govern historic buildings. Both reach into the other paths on this guide: SB 9, the four-unit exception and Housing Choice-SF each have their own tenant and historic tests.

Demolition and historic rules in six facts

Section 317: Losing a Home Needs a Hearing

Planning Code Section 317 covers the loss of residential units through demolition, merger or conversion to another use. Table 209.1, as reprinted in Ordinance No. 245-25 and checked on the page image, sets the control for every RH district at "C." C means Conditional Use Authorization, a public hearing and vote of the Planning Commission. The row now reads "Residential Conversion, Demolition, or Merger of Dwelling Units, including Residential Flats." The Family Zoning Plan added the last words and a definition: a Residential Flat is a unit "in a building containing two or more Dwelling Units, that has contiguous habitable space that extends the full depth of the building on the same story from the front street-facing façade to the rear of the building."

That wording protects the classic San Francisco flat, one unit per floor running front to back. Merging two flats into one home now needs a hearing, and Section 207.10 adds a size cap: a merger in a project filed after January 31, 2026 is limited to "4,000 square feet of Gross Floor Area or an equivalent Floor Area Ratio for any individual Dwelling Unit of 1.2:1, whichever is greater," unless the Commission approves a larger unit.

Two state paths skip the hearing. SF Planning's Director Bulletin No. 8 says that because SB 9 and SB 684 projects are ministerial, "conditional use authorization for demolition under Planning Code Section 317 will not be required," though "The permit for the new units must be approved at the same time as the demolition permit." Both state laws keep their own tenant limits, which the ADUs and SB 9 page lists.

The 2026 Tenant Protection Ordinance

The Family Zoning Plan page says the rezoning "was complemented by the Tenant Protection Ordinance also adopted in December 2025." The ordinance is No. 003-26, Board File 250926, introduced by Supervisor Chyanne Chen; the signed copy shows it finally passed January 6, 2026, and SF Planning's code summary gives February 9, 2026 as the effective date. It added Planning Code Section 317.2, which "codifies and expands upon SB 330 requirements for housing replacement and tenant protections." SB 330 is the state Housing Crisis Act, which bars a net loss of homes. The summary lists five Planning Code changes:

  • owners "seeking to demolish residential units" must "replace all units that are being demolished";
  • demolition permits are barred "for five years if a tenant vacated a unit in the building to be demolished due to harassment or under an improper buyout agreement," subject to conditions;
  • relocation help is owed to occupants and to some former occupants who left after buyouts, owner move-ins, Ellis Act withdrawals or serious hazards;
  • the definition of demolition changed;
  • the criteria for the demolition hearing changed.
Topic Before Since February 9, 2026
Replacement Equivalent-sized units, meaning the same number of bedrooms Comparable Units: same bedrooms, same full bathrooms, at least 90% of the square footage
Hearing criteria 18 non-objective criteria in Section 317(g)(6) 8 objective criteria for projects demolishing or building 2 or more units; 6 of 8 needed
Look-back for the hearing exemption outside Priority Equity Geographies 5 years 10 years
Lower-income tenant right to remain Up to 6 months before demolition Up to 3 months, plus Ellis-level relocation benefits and a right of first refusal
Deed-restricted replacement units 55-year restriction Affordable for the life of the project
Enforcement No private right of action Tenants and nonprofits may sue for violations of Section 317.2

Source: SF Planning, Tenant Protections Related to Residential Demolitions and Renovations code summary, items 4, 6, 7, 10, 14 and 17.

What Counts as Demolition

The new definition matters most to owners who plan a large remodel. Before 2026, Section 317 had two tests for a remodel "tantamount to demolition." The summary says the single test now is: "A major alteration of a Residential Building that proposes the Removal of 50% or more of the sum of the combined Front Façade and Rear Façade and 50% or more of the Horizontal Elements of the existing building, as measured in square feet of actual surface area." Horizontal Elements is the code's term for the horizontal parts of the building.

The summary adds that infilling an existing exterior opening counts as removal, and that "the elevation of an entire building, regardless of height," counts as removal of horizontal elements. Moving a building to another spot without such alterations does not. A project that meets the definition must meet Section 317.2, and SF Planning says it uses the same definition "when implementing state laws." In practice, an owner raising a house to add a garage floor or a third unit should have the facades and floors measured before filing.

The Hearing, Replacement Units and Tenant Rights

The hearing criteria in Section 317(g)(6) were "simplified to eight objective criteria to be used for developments requiring demolition of 2 or more units or the development of 2 or more units." The summary says "Projects must meet 70% of the criteria (six out of the eight criteria) to avoid denial," and criteria that do not apply count as met. A project that demolishes one unit and builds one is judged under the general Conditional Use findings of Section 303(c). Outside the Priority Equity Geographies, a project can still be exempt from the hearing in some cases; the look-back for one of those tests, whether removed units were rent controlled, deed restricted or last occupied by a lower-income household, grew to 10 years.

Replacement now has a set meaning. A protected unit must be replaced with a Comparable Unit, which has "the same number of bedrooms, same number of full bathrooms, and at least 90% of the square footage of the protected units being replaced." The summary says the replacement rules the Department used before are now codified: for example, rent-controlled units occupied by households above lower income were replaced as rent-controlled rentals, or as below-market ownership units at 80 percent of area median income, and units of lower-income tenants as deed-restricted affordable housing. Replacement units now count toward inclusionary requirements.

Existing occupants include tenants living there when the development or preliminary application is filed, and some who left earlier: within five years after a non-compliant buyout, an Ellis Act withdrawal or a "serious and eminent hazard," or within three years after an owner move-in eviction. Lower-income households have a right to remain until three months before demolition, relocation benefits "comparable to those for Ellis Act Evictions," additional relocation benefits and a right of first refusal for a Comparable Unit "at prior rental rate or affordable rent, whichever is lower." Notices are required from application to completion, and a compliant relocation plan is needed for the demolition permit. Tenants and nonprofits representing them may sue over violations of Section 317.2.

Older rules still apply alongside. The Family Zoning Plan page says rent control "Applies to most multi-family buildings built before June 1979," and that just cause eviction protections apply to most tenants after 12 months. Ordinance No. 170-25 requires applicants to "disclose the presence of any Unauthorized Dwelling Unit," and requires the Planning Department "to inspect properties prior to recommending approval of any loss of a Residential Unit or Unauthorized Dwelling Unit." An unauthorized unit is a home created without permits, and the summary says the codified no net loss rule "includes authorized and unauthorized units."

Historic Buildings: Articles 10 and 11

San Francisco has three levels of historic listing, according to SF Planning's historic preservation FAQ: local (Articles 10 and 11 of the Planning Code), state (the California Register) and federal (the National Register). The FAQ counts "over 300 designated Article 10 Landmarks and over 1,110 lots within the designated Article 10 Historic Districts," over 120 buildings individually on the National Register, 24 National Register historic districts, and over 3,300 parcels "listed in or determined eligible for listing in the California Register." It adds that "relatively few buildings in San Francisco have been officially listed" because many have never been surveyed.

Listing Review for changes Planning fee (FY 2026-27)
Article 10 landmark Certificate of Appropriateness for exterior work needing a permit; demolition moratorium of up to one year Full COA $9,214 at $20,000 or more of construction
Article 10 historic district Certificate of Appropriateness for exterior work, including non-contributory buildings and new buildings Same
Article 11 conservation district Separate Permit to Alter process; downtown core only Major Permit to Alter $13,433
California or National Register No Certificate of Appropriateness unless also Article 10; CEQA review Historic Resources Review $2,766

Sources: SF Planning, Historic Preservation FAQs; Fee Schedule notice, effective August 31, 2026.

Article 10 adds "two additional layers of protection." The FAQ explains: "a moratorium of up to one-year can be placed on demolition permits in order to explore feasible alternatives to demolition," and exterior alterations need a Certificate of Appropriateness (COA), or an Administrative COA for minor work that staff can approve. The Historic Preservation Commission reviews full COAs. Inside an Article 10 district, "Even buildings rated as Non-Contributory" need a COA, and so does any new building. Article 11 conservation districts are "located exclusively in San Francisco's downtown core area," with buildings rated in categories I to V. Even unlisted buildings may be historic: under the state's environmental review law, the FAQ says, "all buildings constructed over 50 years ago may be historical resources."

How Historic Status Changes Each Housing Path

  • SB 9. Director Bulletin No. 8 says parcels are not eligible if they are in a state historic district or designated under Article 10 or 11.
  • Four-unit exception. The project must show it will not cause "a substantial adverse change to the significance of a historic resource."
  • Housing Choice-SF. The R-4 district leaves out lots with Article 10 landmarks or district contributors, and the program bars demolition of those buildings, Article 11 Significant or Contributory buildings, and California or National Register buildings.
  • Section 207.11 near transit. Lots with Article 10 landmarks or contributors, or Article 11 buildings in Categories I to IV, are left out.
  • Lot mergers. Section 121.7(e) bars mergers for housing on lots with certain historic buildings unless the building is kept.
  • ADUs. Ordinance No. 222-25 says a State Program ADU on a historic property must meet the Historic Preservation Commission's objective standards and "shall not be required to obtain a Certificate of Appropriateness or a Permit to Alter."

SF Planning's historic factsheet says "Historic designation does not prevent new housing," and that Preservation Design Standards adopted in 2024 give "objective standards for property owners looking to alter or modify historic buildings." Its examples include 2411 Webster Street, a historic Pacific Heights apartment building where "Existing garages were converted into new homes" as two ADUs. The Family Zoning Plan page reports that from 2012 to 2025, "269 Units have been demolished" in the city, and says demolitions "have remained rare even during boom periods." The rent and tenant rules page covers the state rent cap and the Ellis Act.

Best For

  • ✓ An owner-occupied or vacant house with no tenant history, where SB 9 avoids the Section 317 hearing.
  • ✓ A remodel kept under the 50 percent facade and floor thresholds, so it is not a demolition.
  • ✓ A historic building where converted or detached State Program ADUs add homes without a COA.

Usually Fails When

  • ✕ A tenant left after a buyout or harassment finding in the past five years, which can bar the demolition permit.
  • ✕ The pro forma assumes market rents on replacement units for protected tenants.
  • ✕ The building is an Article 10 landmark or contributor and the plan relies on R-4 or Section 207.11.

What To Verify Before Spending Money

  • → Rent Board records of evictions, buyouts and tenancy for the past ten years.
  • → Historic status in the Property Information Map, including California Register eligibility.
  • → Facade and floor removal percentages measured before the permit is filed.

Where to Go Next

Related on VanPlex: the San Francisco overview and rent and tenant rules in California.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I demolish a house in San Francisco to build more units? +
Yes, but in RH districts it needs Conditional Use Authorization under San Francisco Planning Code Section 317, and since February 9, 2026 the Tenant Protection Ordinance requires every demolished unit to be replaced. SB 9 and SB 684 projects are the exception: SF Planning Director Bulletin No. 8 says they need no Conditional Use for demolition.
What is the Tenant Protection Ordinance in San Francisco? +
The San Francisco Tenant Protection Ordinance is Ordinance No. 003-26, passed January 6, 2026 and effective February 9, 2026. It added Planning Code Section 317.2, requires replacement of all demolished units, sets relocation benefits and a right of first refusal, and bars demolition permits for five years after certain harassment findings or improper buyouts.
What counts as a demolition in San Francisco? +
Since February 9, 2026, the San Francisco Planning Code treats as demolition a major alteration that removes 50 percent or more of the combined front and rear facades and 50 percent or more of the building's horizontal elements, measured by surface area. Raising a whole building now counts as removing horizontal elements, while moving a building intact does not.
What is a Comparable Unit in San Francisco demolition rules? +
A Comparable Unit is the replacement standard in the San Francisco Tenant Protection Ordinance. A protected unit must be replaced with one that has the same number of bedrooms and full bathrooms and at least 90 percent of the square footage. Before 2026 the City required only the same number of bedrooms.
Which tenants count as existing occupants for San Francisco demolition rules? +
Under the San Francisco Tenant Protection Ordinance, existing occupants include tenants living there when the application is filed and tenants who left within five years after a non-compliant buyout, an Ellis Act eviction or a serious hazard, or within three years after an owner move-in eviction. They are owed relocation benefits and a right of first refusal.
How many historic landmarks does San Francisco have? +
SF Planning says San Francisco has over 300 designated Article 10 landmarks and over 1,110 lots within Article 10 historic districts. It also counts over 120 buildings individually on the National Register, 24 National Register historic districts, and over 3,300 parcels listed in or found eligible for the California Register.
Do I need a Certificate of Appropriateness in San Francisco? +
Yes, for exterior work needing a permit on an Article 10 landmark or any building in an Article 10 historic district, even a non-contributory one. SF Planning says buildings listed only on the California or National Register do not need one. The FY 2026-27 San Francisco fee notice lists a full Certificate of Appropriateness at $9,214 for work of $20,000 or more.
Can I add an ADU to a historic building in San Francisco? +
Yes. San Francisco Ordinance No. 222-25 says a State Program ADU on an Article 10 or 11 property or a California Register property must meet the Historic Preservation Commission's objective standards but needs no Certificate of Appropriateness or Permit to Alter. SF Planning's factsheet shows 2411 Webster Street, where garages in a historic Pacific Heights building became two ADUs.
Can I merge two flats into one home in San Francisco? +
Only with approval, and with a size cap. San Francisco Table 209.1 requires Conditional Use Authorization to merge dwelling units in RH districts, and the Family Zoning Plan added Residential Flats to that rule. Planning Code Section 207.10 also limits a unit created by a merger after January 31, 2026 to 4,000 square feet unless the Commission approves more.
What is the penalty for removing a unit without a permit in San Francisco? +
The San Francisco Planning fee schedule for FY 2026-27 lists an enforcement penalty of up to $250,000 per unit for removal of a dwelling unit or addition of four or more unauthorized units, up to $500,000 per structure for significant alteration or demolition of a historic property, and up to $150,000 for misrepresenting tenant information.

Official sources (checked October 2026)

SF Planning, Tenant Protections Related to Residential Demolitions and Renovations code summary (PDF)
https://files.sfplanning.org/documents/legislation/2025-008704PCA-TenantProtectionsOrdinance.pdf
Ordinance No. 003-26, Tenant Protections (PDF)
https://sfgov.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=15067814&GUID=7D1E290A-C730-4A85-981B-D776775A010A
Ordinance No. 245-25, Family Zoning Plan, Table 209.1 and Section 207.10 (PDF)
https://sfgov.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=15031708&GUID=17CB5650-66F2-4C0C-BD85-CBD52393AD7B
Ordinance No. 170-25, Unauthorized and Rent-Controlled Dwelling Units (PDF)
https://sfgov.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=14759077&GUID=612DB822-30EF-4E0B-95C3-4C4F370F19A3
Ordinance No. 222-25, State-Mandated ADU Program (PDF)
https://sfgov.legistar.com/View.ashx?M=F&ID=14982345&GUID=E3649C07-AEA5-4918-B829-C58BFB939D27
SF Planning, Family Zoning Plan
https://sfplanning.org/sf-family-zoning-plan
SF Planning, Historic Preservation and the Family Zoning Plan factsheet (PDF)
https://sfplanning.org/sites/default/files/documents/citywide/FZP-Factsheet-Historic-Preservation.pdf
SF Planning, Historic Preservation FAQs
https://sfplanning.org/historic-preservation-faqs
SF Planning, Director Bulletin No. 8, Streamlined Housing Development
https://sfplanning.org/resource/planning-director-bulletin-no-8-streamlined-housing-development
SF Planning, Fee Schedule FY 2026-27 notice (PDF)
https://sfplanning.org/sites/default/files/documents/admin/fee_schedule_FY26-27_notification.pdf
Government Code 65852.21 (SB 9 two-unit projects)
https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySection.xhtml?lawCode=GOV&sectionNum=65852.21
VanPlex newsletter

Get new guides by email

New VanPlex guides and articles on multiplex rules, building costs and permits, sent to your inbox.

General information, not legal advice. California housing law changes every year, and each city adds its own rules on top of state law. Confirm current requirements with the city or county planning department, and with a California-licensed attorney or architect, before you buy land or file plans.

Planning a multiplex in San Francisco?

VanPlex builds multiplexes in British Columbia, Canada. For a lot in San Francisco, our team makes a custom proforma by hand and emails it to you in 24 to 48 hours.

Get a proforma for your address